Cover photo for Dr. Andrew Eldon Stoner's Obituary
Dr. Andrew Eldon Stoner Profile Photo
1964 Dr. Andrew 2022

Dr. Andrew Eldon Stoner

March 13, 1964 — February 9, 2022

Andrew Stoner obituary

Andrew E. Stoner, PhD, 57, passed away Feb. 9, 2022, in Sacramento, California, after a month-long illness. Andrew, Drew, Andy or Dr. Stoner was a journalist, public relations practitioner, prolific author and eventually a well-loved professor. At the time of his passing, he was an associate professor at California State University, Sacramento in the Department of Communication Studies.

One friend summed him up well: “he left a long trail of lives that he touched and made better along the way. His legacy will live on in his family, friends, his students and his written words.” He is remembered for his great sense of humor, commitment to “getting it right,” perseverance, loyalty and ability to relate to others and their situations. He possessed a passion for teaching, lifelong learning and an extraordinary commitment to his students and colleagues.

Born March 13, 1964, in Goshen, Indiana, Andrew was the youngest child of Duane E. Stoner and Sandra J. (Palmer) Stoner. He was the grandson of Altis and Frances (Matesick) Stoner and Donald and Opal (Lovejoy) Palmer. Given his deep love for his family and Elkhart County, he will be buried near his parents in Violett Cemetery. 

He is survived by his husband, Randolph Scott, whom he married on Dec. 7, 2015. Together for 26 years, their family included Teddy and Sandy as well as Max, Irma and Gustav, who preceded him in death. In his free time, Andrew enjoyed his pups, classic movies, and the Golden Girls.   He kept up with extended family and friends far and wide. Andrew and Randolph enjoyed their explorations of Northern California and scenic Colorado together.   

Andrew also is survived by two brothers, Charles D. Stoner of South Bend, Indiana, and Kirby A. (Barbara) Stoner of Goshen, Indiana, and a sister, Shelley M. (Steven) Bontrager of Middlebury, Indiana; four nephews, three nieces-in-law, five great-nephews, two great-nieces and another on the way.

A journalist by training, he earned his Ph.D. in Public Communication and Technology from Colorado State University (2013), a master’s degree in Journalism from Ball State University (1995), and a bachelor’s degree in Journalism from Franklin College of Indiana (1986). Andrew was a 1982 graduate of Goshen (Ind.) High School.

Personally and professionally, Andrew stayed involved. He was active in student government, politics, journalism and many other organizations in high school and college. At Franklin, he was also a member of the Lambda Chi Alpha fraternity. During his career, Andrew volunteered his time and effort for multiple organizations including leadership roles and as an active participant in multiple interest groups and divisions of the Association of Education in Journalism and Mass Communication (AEJMC). He stayed active in his communities, past and present, including the Goshen (Ind.) Historical Society, Central Christian Church in Indianapolis and the Pioneer Congregational United Church of Christ in Sacramento. In 2003, he received the Hail to Franklin Award from Franklin College.

Franklin College

A phone call from William A. Bridges, a Franklin College journalism professor, opened the door to Andy’s undergraduate education. Andy is among the prospective students, now alumni, who have cited a personal call from Bill Bridges as being what led to their enrollment.

At Franklin College, Andy made many lifelong friends who truly became members of his family.

A contributor on campus, Andy was a member of Lambda Chi Alpha Fraternity and the Student Foundation and served in various roles on The Franklin student newspaper. He also served as a Pulliam Fellow in the college’s Office of Public Affairs.

Andy was a student at Franklin College during the 1985 fires, which he covered as a journalist. As the son of a fire chief and a student who escaped Bryan Hall, a residence hall gutted by one of the fires, Andy many times was among those interviewed over the months by media outlets.

Franklin College remained a part of Andy’s life. He was a speaker on campus Sept. 14-15, 2017. During that visit he gave a public presentation for Constitution Day, reading from his book, "Campaign Crossroads: Presidential Politics in Indiana from Lincoln to Obama." He also spoke to a series of classes and appeared on the WFYI “No Limits” radio show.

In early December 2021 Andy came to Indiana for the Holiday Book Fair, Indiana Historical Society.  A priority of that trip was gathering with Franklin College friends over that weekend, a visit he and his friends appreciated then and his friends treasure even more now.

A Public Servant…Like His Parents

Andrew was proud of the contributions of his parents who were public servants a number of years.  His father joined the Goshen Fire Department in 1965, serving in several ranks. Andy’s dad was appointed Jan. 1, 1980, as fire chief, by Mayor Max R. Chiddister, serving as chief until his retirement Dec. 31, 1988. His mother was employed as a deputy city clerk in the office of former Goshen Clerk-Treasurer Phyllis D. Roose.

He served as communications director in the office of Indiana State Treasurer Marjorie H. O’Laughlin (1987 - 1989) public information officer for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department (1989 - 1992), public information officer for the Indiana State Department of Health (1994 - 1997), director of communications for the Indiana Family and Social Services Administration (1997 - July 2001), deputy press secretary and executive policy assistant, human services, in the office of Indiana Gov. Frank O’Bannon (2001 - 2003). He was very proud of his service to the citizens of Indiana.

Other Professional Positions

His first job after college graduation was as a general assignment news reporter for The South Bend Tribune in the Elkhart, Indiana, Bureau (1986 - 1987). Other positions included partnership coordinator, Partners in Education Program, Indianapolis Chamber of Commerce (1992 - 1993), director of marketing communications for M-Plan, The HealthCare Group LLC in Indianapolis (2003 - 2007), manager, corporate communications team for Honda Manufacturing of Indiana, LLC, Greensburg, Indiana (2007 - 2009) and managing editor of The Educational Forum, an academic journal, Kappa Delta Pi Educational Foundation, Indianapolis (2009 - August 2010).

Andrew Stoner…The Author

Andrew wrote on a variety of subjects from mass media, politics, history, true-crime, and popular culture. His 12th book, “Fear Hate and Victimhood: How George Wallace Wrote the Donald Trump Playbook” is scheduled for publication this spring by University of Mississippi Press. His most recent book, a labor of love, “Betty White: A Century of Love and Laughs” was a revision of one he wrote on her 90th birthday and won the Silver Medal Benjamin Franklin Digital Award, from the Independent Book Publishers Association of America

In 2021, he authored two books: "Wanted in Indiana: Infamous Hoosier Fugitives" from the History Press, and "Dear Abby, I'm Gay: Newspaper Advice Columnists and Homosexuality" from McFarland Publishing.  Previously, he released "Courthouse Chaos: Famous and Infamous Trials, Mob Violence and Justice" (2021), "Campaign Crossroads: Presidential Politics in Indiana from Lincoln to Obama" (2017), "Notorious 92" (2007), and “Legacy of a Governor: The Life of Indiana's Frank O'Bannon” (2006).

"Cobra Killer" - a book Stoner co-authored with Peter A. Conway (2015) - was recently reissued and was the subject of a segment on "Snapped: Killer Couples" on the Oxygen Network (NBC Universal). Film rights to the book were also sold for a 2016 independent theatrical release, "King Cobra" from James Franco and Justin Kelly.

His dissertation ultimately became "The Journalist of Castro Street: The Life of Randy Shilts" (2019: University of Illinois Press). It is the first-ever biography of the acclaimed author of "And the Band Played On," the country's most recognized tome on the HIV/AIDS epidemic.

Professor Stoner

Dr. Stoner joined the California State University, Sacramento, Department of Communication Studies in September 2015. Other teaching positions included service as an adjunct professor, Center for Professional & Continuing Education at University of the Pacific, Stockton, California; assistant professor and instructor, Division of Communication at University of Wisconsin, Stevens Point, Wisconsin; graduate teaching assistant at Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado; adjunct faculty member at Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana, Indianapolis, Indiana-Purdue University at Indianapolis and Franklin College, Franklin, Indiana.

Memorials may be made to the Indiana Youth Group ( or the Fred Finch Youth Center in Oakland (


Services are preliminarily set for 2 p.m. Saturday, February 26th in Indianapolis at Central Christian Church at 701 N. Delaware Street;   with visitation from 4-8 p.m. Monday, February 28th at Yoder-Culp Funeral Home in Goshen.    Graveside service in Violett Cemetery, Goshen, at 2 p.m. Tuesday, March 1st.  

Arrangements are by East Lawn Mortuary in Sacramento;  Legacy Funeral Services in Indianapolis;  and by Yoder-Culp Mortuary in Goshen.  

To order memorial trees or send flowers to the family in memory of Dr. Andrew Eldon Stoner, please visit our flower store.

Service Schedule

Past Services

Indianapolis Central Christian Church

Indianapolis Central Christian Church

701 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Send Flowers

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.


Yoder-Culp Funeral Home, Goshen, IN

1911 S Main St, Goshen, IN 46526

Send Flowers

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.

Visits: 2

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors

Send Flowers

Send Flowers

Plant A Tree

Plant A Tree